A3 problem solving explained

An A3 is a one-page report that takes a problem from the facts to a tested fix. This guide follows one A3 through six weeks at a made-up plant.

Matt Savas · Reviewed October 2026 · About 8 minutes

What an A3 is

An A3 is a report written on one sheet of A3 paper, 297 by 420 millimeters. Toyota uses the format for problem solving, proposals and status reports. John Shook describes how Toyota managers use it in Managing to Learn (Lean Enterprise Institute, 2008).

A problem-solving A3 has six sections. The left side describes the problem. The right side holds the plan and the results.

  1. Background: what the problem is, who owns it and why it matters now.
  2. Current condition: the facts, measured where the work happens.
  3. Analysis: the causes, found from the facts.
  4. Target condition: the result you want, with a number and a date.
  5. Countermeasures: the changes you will make, each with an owner.
  6. Follow-up: when you will check the result, and what you found.

The sections follow PDCA (plan, do, check, act). The left side and the target are the plan. The countermeasures are the do. The follow-up is the check and act.

Why one page

One sheet holds a few hundred words and a chart or two. The owner has to choose which facts matter, and a reader can see the problem, the cause and the fix at once.

At Toyota the A3 is also a coaching tool. A manager reads the sheet and asks questions about it. The owner goes back to the work to answer them and rewrites the sheet. An A3 usually goes through several versions before anyone signs it.

How to write an A3

  1. Name one owner. Often this is the person closest to the problem, whatever their rank.
  2. Write the background: what the problem is, where it happens and why it matters now.
  3. Go and see. Measure the current condition where the work happens, and note where each fact came from.
  4. Write the problem statement once you have the facts: the gap, the standard, the size and when it started.
  5. Find the causes with a fishbone diagram or the five whys, and check each cause against the data.
  6. Set the target condition with a number and a date.
  7. Choose countermeasures that address the causes. Test the main one on a small scale first, and give each an owner and a date.
  8. Show the A3 to everyone the countermeasures affect, and change it with what they tell you.
  9. Check the result on the date you set, and write down what you learned.

A worked example

Housing defects on Line 3 doubled, from 4% to 8%. The plant manager wanted refresher training for the press operators. Instead, the problem went to Maya Chen, a manufacturing engineer in her second year. Diane Okafor, the operations director, coached her.

Use the buttons to see the sheet at five points over six weeks. Diane’s questions are in amber. The plant, the people and the numbers are made up for this example.

Week 1. Maya’s first draft names a fix and repeats what supervisors say. Diane answers with questions.

1Background

Line 3 housing defect rate. Owner: Maya Chen

Problem: Operators on Line 3 need refresher training on press operation.

Diane: Is this a problem, or a fix you have already picked?

Diane: What is the gap? Against what standard? Since when?

2Current condition

Quality says defects are up. Supervisors report operators rushing.

Diane: How do you know? Where would I see this?

Everyone agrees the new hires are struggling.

3Analysis

Not filled in yet.

4Target condition

Left empty until the analysis is done.

5Countermeasures

Left empty until the analysis is done.

6Follow-up

Left empty until the analysis is done.

The first draft named a fix, training, before anyone had measured anything. The data showed all three shifts with the same defect rate, which ruled training out. The finished sheet names two causes the data supports, and its main countermeasure was tested on one press before it went to the whole line.

How to write the problem statement

A problem statement says four things: the gap between what is happening and what should happen, the standard, the size of the gap in numbers, and when and where it started. It leaves out three things: a cause, a fix and a name.

Here are three drafts of the Line 3 statement.

  • “Line 3 operators need better training and closer supervision to reduce defects.” This is two fixes and no facts.
  • “Defects on Line 3 are unacceptable and must be reduced as soon as possible.” There is no gap, standard or date. It could describe any problem.
  • “The housing defect rate on Line 3 rose from 4% to 8% in the week of March 12. The standard is 4% or less.” This one works. It has the gap, the standard, the size and the timing.

The problem statement sits at the top of the sheet, but write it after the current condition. If you write it first, it describes what you assume. If you write it after, it describes what you measured.

The questions an A3 coach asks

Diane did not write on Maya’s A3. She asked questions, and Maya went back to the line to answer them. When a coach rewrites the sheet, the owner stops doing the thinking. These are the questions a coach asks most often.

  • What problem are you trying to solve, in one sentence, with no cause and no fix?
  • How do you know? Where would I see it?
  • What is the gap, against what standard, since when?
  • Who have you talked to that does this work every day?
  • Is this a problem, or a fix you have already picked?
  • What would have to be true for that cause to produce this data?
  • What did you rule out, and how?
  • What is the smallest test that could prove you wrong?
  • Who has to agree before this works, and have they read it yet?
  • When will you check, and what number will tell you it worked?

One rule applies to every A3: no person is named as a cause. In week 4, Maya’s analysis said the operators were adjusting the press by hand in different ways. Diane asked what made them do it. The answer was the press and the castings, so the line was rewritten as a condition of the process.

Common mistakes

  • Putting a fix in the problem statement. “Operators need training” decides the answer before anyone has looked at the facts.
  • Writing it at a desk. Opinions and old reports go into the current condition as if they were facts. Go to the line and measure.
  • Blaming a person. “Operator error” ends the analysis. Ask what in the process made the error likely.
  • Filling in the right side too early. Countermeasures written before the analysis are guesses.
  • Bringing the A3 to the approval meeting first. The people the countermeasures affect should read it and change it before anyone approves it.
  • Skipping the follow-up. Without a check on a set date, no one knows whether the countermeasures worked.

How to start

Pick a problem you own that has a number attached and is small enough to finish in a few weeks. Write a first draft, then show it to someone who will ask how you know.

The free A3 tool gives you the six sections and prints at A3 size. In the A3 RPG you work the same Line 3 case: you walk the floor, talk to the crew and write the A3. For the analysis section, see the five whys guide and the free fishbone tool. Two more guides show A3s in healthcare and manufacturing.

The Lean Enterprise Institute also has a short definition of the A3 report.

Frequently asked questions

What is A3 problem solving?
A3 problem solving is a method from Toyota for working through a problem on one A3-size sheet of paper. The sheet has six sections: background, current condition, analysis, target condition, countermeasures and follow-up. The owner gathers facts where the work happens before proposing a fix, looks for causes in the process instead of in people, and shows the sheet to everyone it affects before it is approved.
How do you write a good A3 problem statement?
State the gap against a standard, with its size, where it happens and when it started. "The defect rate rose from 4% to 8% beginning March 12; the standard is 4%" is a problem statement. "Operators need more training" is a fix, and it ends the investigation before it starts. If your statement contains a cause, a fix or a name, rewrite it.
What questions does an A3 coach ask?
Questions that test whether the owner has seen the problem: How do you know? Where would I see it? What did you rule out? What is the smallest test that could prove you wrong? Who does this work every day, and what did they say? A coach does not correct the sheet. The owner goes back to the work to answer each question.
How long should an A3 take?
Days to weeks, most of it away from the desk. Writing the sheet is quick. Going to see, measuring, testing countermeasures and showing the sheet to others take most of the time. An A3 finished in an afternoon usually holds what people already believed before they started.